... the sign and the song ...
The Sign and the Song Meaning, Melos, and the Appearance of Necessity Meaning is not what music says. Meaning is what becomes necessary while music lives. I. The Question Mislaid There is a question that the whole modern science of meaning has asked with such persistence, and answered with such ingenuity, that we have forgotten it was ever a choice to ask it. The question is what does this mean?, where mean is understood as a relation, a bridge thrown across a gap, a rope tying a sign to something on the far side of it. What does this word refer to, this sentence assert, this gesture signify, this passage evoke, this cadence connote? The question presupposes that meaning is a possession , that things have meanings the way bodies have weight, that meaning is a content lodged somewhere, behind the sound, beneath the surface, inside the sign, in the mind of the speaker, in the convention of the tribe, waiting to be extracted, decoded,...